See all results on the search page

    The Existence of God: an argument for God

    Can God's existence be proved from the idea of God? The ontological argument

    The ontological argument holds that God's existence follows from the idea of God as a being than which nothing greater can be conceived. Anselm of Canterbury gave it its classic form, and Rene Descartes and Alvin Plantinga gave it new ones. Critics, from Gaunilo to Immanuel Kant, question whether anything's existence can follow from an idea alone.

    • 15 minute read
    • Last reviewed:

    The classical argument: must the greatest conceivable being exist?

    This version, first set out by Anselm of Canterbury and later recast by Rene Descartes, argues from an idea alone, without observing the world. Its defenders include Anselm and Descartes; its critics include Gaunilo, a monk of Anselm's own time, and Immanuel Kant.

    For the argumentAgainst the argumentWhat both sides accept

    The argument, as its defenders state it:

    1. Premise 1Even someone who denies God understands the idea of a being than which nothing greater can be conceived, so that being exists in the understanding.
    2. Premise 2Existing in reality is greater than existing in the understanding alone.
    3. ConclusionTherefore, a being than which nothing greater can be conceived exists, both in the understanding and in reality.

    1Premise 1Even someone who denies God understands the idea of a being than which nothing greater can be conceived, so that being exists in the understanding.

    What both sides acceptAnselm's figure of the one who denies God comes from Psalm 14:1, which calls such a person a fool. To exist "in the understanding" is to be thought of: a painter, Anselm writes, has a picture in his understanding before he paints it, though he does not yet understand it to exist.1

    For the argument

    For the argumentTo understand the idea is to have it in mind

    Anselm argues that when the one who denies God hears of a being than which nothing greater can be conceived, he understands what he hears, and whatever is understood exists in the understanding. Replying to Gaunilo, Anselm appealed to Gaunilo's own faith and conscience that such a being is truly understood.12

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentNot everyone means this by "God"

    Thomas Aquinas answers that perhaps not everyone who hears the word "God" takes it to mean something than which nothing greater can be thought, since some have believed God to be a body. Even granted that meaning, he argues, it follows only that God exists in the mind, not that God exists in reality.34

    Reply, for the argumentThe argument works without a definition of God

    Kenneth Einar Himma, the author of the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy's entry, replies that the argument can be restated without defining God, by speaking only of a being than which none greater can be conceived. Nor does it need a complete grasp of that idea: if the idea is coherent, he argues, even a minimal understanding is enough.4

    Against the argumentFirst establish that the idea is possible

    Gottfried Leibniz held that Descartes's version fails unless one first establishes that the idea of a supremely perfect being is coherent, that is, that such a being could exist.5

    Reply, for the argumentPerfections cannot be shown to conflict

    Leibniz answered his own challenge. Since perfections cannot be analyzed, he argued, it is impossible to demonstrate that any of them are incompatible, and he concluded that all perfections can exist together in a single being.5

    Reply, against the argumentSome perfections may exclude others

    C. D. Broad argues that unless every positive property is compatible with every other, the phrase "a being than which none greater can be imagined" is empty, like "the greatest possible integer." Himma points to arguments that perfect justice and perfect mercy conflict, and that knowing everything people will do conflicts with the power to create free beings.4

    2Premise 2Existing in reality is greater than existing in the understanding alone.

    What both sides acceptPhilosophers call a quality that makes a being greater, all else being equal, a great-making property or a perfection. This premise treats existence in reality as one.4

    For the argument

    For the argumentExistence belongs to the idea of a perfect being

    Rene Descartes, in the seventeenth century, made a parallel argument: God has every perfection, and necessary, independent existence is one of them. To exclude any perfection from the idea of a supremely perfect being, he holds, is a contradiction, like conceiving a mountain without a valley.56

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentExistence is not a real predicate

    Pierre Gassendi, in the Fifth Objections to Descartes, answered that existence is not a perfection but that without which no perfections can be present. Immanuel Kant argued that existence is not a real predicate: the idea of a hundred real thalers, coins of Kant's day, is no different from the idea of a hundred possible ones, so saying that a thing exists adds nothing to its concept.64

    Reply, for the argumentExistence is no property, yet a perfect being must exist

    Moses Mendelssohn dismissed the objection as a quibble. He granted that existence is not one more property to add to a list, but held that only something contingent can be thought of without it: a perfect being either cannot be thought of at all or must be thought of as actually existing.7

    Reply, for the argumentNecessary existence sets God apart

    Lawrence Nolan, the author of the Stanford Encyclopedia's entry on Descartes's argument, argues that Descartes had an answer. Descartes agreed that existence adds nothing to an idea, but held that the idea of God alone contains necessary, independent existence, while the ideas of finite things contain only possible existence.6

    Against the argumentExisting does not make a thing better

    Norman Malcolm found the idea that existence is a perfection "remarkably queer." A future house will be better if it is insulated, he wrote, but it makes no sense to say that it will be better if it exists than if it does not.4

    Reply, for the argumentNecessary existence is a perfection

    Malcolm held that Anselm's main argument comes in the Proslogion's third chapter, which relies instead on necessary existence: a being that cannot be conceived not to exist is greater than one that can. Dishes that are not fragile are better than fragile ones, Malcolm writes, and what depends on nothing is superior to what depends on anything.514

    Reply, against the argumentNecessary existence adds nothing of value

    Himma answers that it is hard to see what existing in every possible world, every world that could have been, adds to a being that is already indestructible in this one. In his view necessary existence adds nothing in value to eternal existence, and if so, Anselm's second version also fails.4

    3ConclusionTherefore, a being than which nothing greater can be conceived exists, both in the understanding and in reality.

    For the argument

    For the argumentTo deny it would be a contradiction

    If the argument succeeds, Himma writes, it is as much a contradiction to suppose that God does not exist as to suppose that there are square circles. In his next chapter, Anselm addresses this being as God, who cannot even be conceived not to exist.41

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentThe same reasoning would yield a perfect island

    Gaunilo, a monk of Marmoutier, answered Anselm in In Behalf of the Fool. Before inferring anything from a being's greatness, he argued, one must first establish that it really exists. Imagine a lost island richer than all other lands. If someone argued that it must exist, because we understand the description and existing in reality is more excellent, Gaunilo would either think he was joking or wonder which of them was the greater fool.24

    Reply, for the argumentThe reasoning fits only the greatest being

    Anselm replied that his reasoning applies to nothing except that than which a greater cannot be conceived, which cannot be conceived not to exist. If anyone could adapt it to anything else, he promised, "I will discover that thing, and will give him his lost island, not to be lost again."2

    Reply, for the argumentIslands have no greatest form

    Alvin Plantinga answers that any island can be improved, for example by adding more palm trees, so there is no greatest possible island. Himma, following Broad, adds that knowledge, power, and goodness have built-in maximums, such as knowing every truth, while the qualities that make an island great do not.54

    Reply, against the argumentA parody can use something that has a maximum

    Graham Oppy, Joshua Rasmussen, and Joseph Schmid, the authors of the Stanford Encyclopedia's entry, reply that more palm trees would eventually overcrowd an island, and that no one knows in advance that islands lack a best balance of good features. In any case, they argue, the parody can be rebuilt around something with a maximum, such as the highest possible score on a test.5

    Against the argumentIt assumes what it sets out to establish

    William Rowe argues that ontological arguments are question-begging: they presuppose the very conclusion they set out to reach. Oppy, Rasmussen, and Schmid note that almost all such general objections rest on far more controversial assumptions than nontheists require in order to reject ontological arguments in good conscience.5

    This version, developed by Charles Hartshorne, Norman Malcolm, and Alvin Plantinga, uses modal logic, the logic of what is possible and what is necessary. It reasons that if a being that would exist necessarily is even possible, then it exists.

    Where does the argument come from?

    The argument is usually traced to Anselm of Canterbury (about 1033 to 1109).45 Anselm set it out in the Proslogion, dated to 1078, a work in which he addresses God directly.51 He first titled it Faith Seeking Understanding, and in it he writes that he believes in order to understand.1 Several scholars hold that an earlier argument by Avicenna (Ibn Sina, about 980 to 1037), about a being whose existence is necessary in itself, could be read as ontological.1112

    Gaunilo, a monk of Marmoutier and Anselm's contemporary, answered soon after with In Behalf of the Fool, and Anselm wrote a reply.52 Thomas Aquinas (about 1225 to 1274) denied that Anselm's argument has any force as a demonstration of God's existence.13 In the seventeenth century, Rene Descartes defended a family of similar arguments and answered objections from critics including Johannes Caterus, Marin Mersenne, and Pierre Gassendi.56 Gottfried Leibniz (1646 to 1716) tried to complete Descartes's argument by arguing that the idea of a supremely perfect being is consistent.58

    Immanuel Kant (1724 to 1804) made perhaps the best-known criticisms, in his Critique of Pure Reason, above all the objection that existence is not a real predicate.54 Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel said in lectures of 1831 that the ontological argument succeeds, though he did not make clear what he took its premises to be.5 Gottlob Frege argued in 1884 that existence is a second-order predicate, so that saying a particular thing exists is meaningless. If so, ontological arguments, whose conclusions say just that, are doomed.5

    The twentieth century brought modal versions, which reason from what is possible to what is necessary.5 Charles Hartshorne defended them in Man's Vision of God (1941), Norman Malcolm in "Anselm's Ontological Arguments" (1960), and Alvin Plantinga in The Nature of Necessity (1974).5 Kurt Godel wrote a version built on the idea of "positive properties," published in his Collected Works in 1995.5

    Across traditions

    For Buddhism and the Latter-day Saint faith, the sources used for this page record no distinctive response to the ontological argument.

    In Christianity, thinkers divided over the argument: Anselm, whom Thomas Williams calls the outstanding Christian philosopher and theologian of the eleventh century, made it.14 Not every advocate of the view that God is a perfect being accepts the argument, Charles Taliaferro notes, and Aquinas famously did not.9 Aquinas held that "God exists" is self-evident in itself, since God is his own existence.3 But it is not self-evident to us, he argued, because we do not know God's essence, so it must be demonstrated from God's effects.3

    Gaunilo, too, wrote as a believer: Anselm answered him as "a Catholic, speaking in behalf of the fool," and Gaunilo praised the rest of the Proslogion.2 The Protestant Reformers, Brian Morley writes, relied heavily on revelation for their idea of God.15 They held that the human mind is darkened by corruption and so is inadequate to shape concepts of God.15

    In Hinduism, the sources used for this page record no ontological argument in classical thought, where schools differed over whether reason can reach God at all.1617 Nyaya philosophers, who took it upon themselves to defend God's existence, reasoned chiefly from the world to its maker.16

    Ramanuja (1017 to 1137 by traditional accounts) gave philosophical form to the Sri Vaishnava tradition of devotion to Vishnu.17 He held that scripture is a means of knowledge whose truth neither the senses nor reason can independently establish.17 For Ramanuja, to know Brahman is to perceive it directly, and devotion (bhakti) is such knowledge: a kind of seeing, he insists, with the character of direct perception.17 A modern defender of the modal argument, Alexander Pruss, draws on a principle he attributes to Shankara, the eighth-century teacher of Advaita Vedanta: nothing impossible can even appear.1018 Shankara, Pruss reports, used it against Buddhist thinkers who held the outside world to be a mere seeming.10

    In Islam, Avicenna argued from the idea of existence itself.1119 Anything that exists, considered in itself, either has existence necessarily or needs something else to give it existence, he held. A chain of such needs cannot go on forever, so it must end in a being that exists necessarily in itself.11 Avicenna held that metaphysics can establish God's existence without relying on the senses, and several scholars have read his argument as ontological, or a priori.11 He called it burhan al-siddiqin, which Sajjad Rizvi translates as the "proof of the veracious."19

    Mulla Sadra (about 1571 to 1636), whom Rizvi calls arguably the most significant Islamic philosopher after Avicenna, developed what Rizvi calls his own ontological argument.19 He held that Avicenna's argument engaged with the concept of existence but not its concrete reality.19 The reality of existence, Mulla Sadra argued, is simple and has no essence, and so is identical with the Necessary, God.19 For him, the veracious, the siddiqin of the argument's name, are those with intuition and inner disclosure, attained through grace and spiritual exercise.19

    In Judaism, Moses Mendelssohn (1729 to 1786), whose writings and Jewish heritage placed him at the center of the German Enlightenment, held throughout his career that God's existence can be demonstrated.7 One of his ways of establishing it with certainty starts from the idea of God.7 If God did not exist, he reasoned in Morning Hours (1785), the idea of God would be either impossible, because self-contradictory, or merely possible, that is, contingent.7 A perfect being cannot be contingent, since contingency means dependence, and its idea contains no contradiction, so God exists.7

    In Jerusalem (1783), he argued that Judaism contains no revealed truths beyond the reach of unaided reason, though at times he applied this only to its essentials.7

    Where does the debate stand?

    Charles Taliaferro, in the Stanford Encyclopedia's entry on philosophy of religion, names Plantinga, Hartshorne, Malcolm, and Clement Dore as authors of current versions of the argument.9 Among its many current critics he lists William Rowe, Jonathan Barnes, Graham Oppy, and J. L. Mackie.95 The two latest book-length treatments he names are both defenses: Daniel Dombrowski's Rethinking the Ontological Argument (2006) and Yujin Nagasawa's Maximal God (2017).9 Brian Leftow's Anselm's Argument (2022) is another recent defense.5

    Oppy, Rasmussen, and Schmid report fairly widespread agreement, even among theists, that no known ontological argument gives reasonable nontheists a reason to believe.5 Most kinds have some defenders, they add, but none has a large following.5 They also hold that it remains an open question whether a version not yet found could succeed, and that theists may reasonably find the premises of some versions intuitive.5 Bertrand Russell remarked, they note, that it is much easier to be persuaded that ontological arguments are no good than to say exactly what is wrong with them, which, they suggest, helps explain why the arguments have fascinated philosophers for almost a thousand years.5

    Common questions

    What is the ontological argument?

    It is an argument for God from the idea of God alone, without observing the world. Anselm of Canterbury argued that a being than which nothing greater can be conceived must exist in reality, since existing in reality is greater than existing only in the mind. Critics question whether existence can follow from an idea.

    What did Kant mean by saying existence is not a predicate?

    Immanuel Kant argued that saying a thing exists adds nothing to the idea of it: the idea of a hundred real coins is no different from the idea of a hundred possible ones. So existence cannot be one of the perfections contained in the idea of God. Defenders answer that necessary existence, unlike ordinary existence, is a perfection.

    What is the modal ontological argument?

    It is a version developed by Charles Hartshorne, Norman Malcolm, and Alvin Plantinga. It argues that if a maximally great being is even possible, it exists in every possible world, and so in ours. Critics answer that the same logic, starting from the possibility that God does not exist, concludes that God cannot exist.

    Read next

    Sources

    1. Anselm of Canterbury. Proslogium, translated by Sidney Norton Deane. Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University (from Open Court, 1903), 1903. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    2. Gaunilo of Marmoutier and Anselm of Canterbury. In Behalf of the Fool, and Anselm's Apologetic in Reply, translated by Sidney Norton Deane. Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University (from Open Court, 1903), 1903. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    3. Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae, First Part, Question 2 (The Existence of God). New Advent (Fathers of the English Dominican Province translation, second revised edition, 1920), 1920, First Part, Question 2, Article 3, with Objection 1 and its reply. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    4. Kenneth Einar Himma. Anselm: Ontological Argument for God's Existence. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    5. Graham Oppy, Joshua Rasmussen, and Joseph Schmid. Ontological Arguments. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2024. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    6. Lawrence Nolan. Descartes' Ontological Argument. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    7. Daniel Dahlstrom. Moses Mendelssohn. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    8. Chad Meister. Philosophy of Religion. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    9. Charles Taliaferro. Philosophy of Religion. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    10. Alexander R. Pruss. Samkara's Principle and Two Ontomystical Arguments. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 49 (2001), 111 to 120 (Kluwer), author's copy on his website, 2001. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    11. Olga Lizzini. Ibn Sina's Metaphysics. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2026. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    12. Frank Griffel. al-Ghazali. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2026. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    13. Robert Pasnau. Thomas Aquinas. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    14. Thomas Williams. Anselm of Canterbury. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    15. Brian Morley. Western Concepts of God. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    16. Matthew R. Dasti. Nyaya. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, introduction and section 3. Accessed 2026-10-29.
    17. Shyam Ranganathan. Ramanuja. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 2026-10-29.
    18. Neil Dalal. Sankara. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2021, introduction and section 1. Accessed 2026-10-29.
    19. Sajjad Rizvi. Mulla Sadra. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2019. Accessed 2026-11-20.