The Existence of God: an argument for God
Does life show signs of design? Paley, Darwin, and intelligent design
The design argument holds that living things, like a watch, have parts fitted together for a purpose, and so had a designer. William Paley made the classic case, and intelligent design writers such as Michael Behe defend a modern form. Critics answer that natural selection explains the appearance of design, and many theists hold that God works through evolution.
- 16 minute read
- Last reviewed:
The argument, step by step
Here the argument's defenders are William Paley and, today, the intelligent design writers Phillip Johnson, Michael Behe, and William Dembski. Its critics include scientists who hold that evolution explains the appearance of design, and theists who hold that God works through evolution rather than by intervening in it, among them Asa Gray, who argued that natural selection is not inconsistent with natural theology.
The argument, as its defenders state it:
- Premise 1Living things, such as the eye, have parts framed and put together for a purpose, as a watch does.
- Premise 2Such features could not have been produced by unguided natural processes.
- ConclusionSo living things are the products of intentional design by an intelligent agent.
- From a designer to GodThe designer is God.
1Premise 1Living things, such as the eye, have parts framed and put together for a purpose, as a watch does.
What both sides acceptOpponents of design arguments also describe living things as looking designed. The biologist Francis Crick warned his colleagues to keep in mind that what they see was not designed but evolved, and Richard Dawkins described biology as the study of complicated things that appear to have been designed for a purpose. Del Ratzsch and Jeffrey Koperski, the authors of the Stanford Encyclopedia's entry, call the claim that some things in nature look designed not particularly controversial even now.1
For the argument
For the argumentPurpose can be seen in the parts, as in a watch
Against the argument
Against the argumentLiving things are not much like machines
David Hume argued in his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779) that nature differs from human artifacts in important ways: living things are alive and sustain themselves, as machines are not, and the cosmos looks more like a living thing than a machine. If the likeness is distant, he held, the inference to a designer is fragile, and other explanations, such as chance, remain open.1
Reply, for the argumentPaley's argument does not rest on analogy
Ratzsch and Koperski read Paley's watch not as half of an analogy but as a clear case of reasoning to design, applied directly to living things. Such an argument would escape the weaknesses of analogy, and it has been argued that Paley built it to avoid Hume's attacks.1
2Premise 2Such features could not have been produced by unguided natural processes.
What both sides acceptThat living things have evolved is a matter of wide agreement among scientists: in a 2009 Pew Research Center survey of members of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 97 percent said humans and other living things have evolved over time. Behe, a leading defender of intelligent design, writes that descent with modification is well supported and that he disputes the mechanism of natural selection, not common descent. Michael Ruse reports that most intelligent design writers accept a long history of the earth and common descent.3456
For the argument
For the argumentSome systems in the cell are irreducibly complex
Michael Behe, a biochemist at Lehigh University, argues in Darwin's Black Box (1996) that some systems in the cell need several well-matched parts, each required for the system to work, such as the motor-driven flagellum some bacteria use to move. Such a system cannot be built directly, by slight, successive improvements of a precursor that works the same way, he holds, since a precursor missing a part would not work.67
Reply, against the argumentParts can become essential over time
H. Allen Orr, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Rochester, agreed in a review that many biological systems are irreducibly complex, but argued that evolution can, at least in theory, build them gradually. A part added because it helps can later become essential, he wrote, as lungs, at first merely useful, became essential to animals that lived on land.5
Reply, for the argumentOrr's examples are not single systems
Behe replied in 2001 that his definition concerns a single system at the molecular level, and that an organ such as the lung is built from many such systems whose origins, he holds, are not yet explained. Prompted by Robert Pennock and others, he granted that the definition looks at removing parts, while evolution's hard task is to assemble a new system, a defect he hoped to repair.5
Reply, against the argumentMiller points to studies of possible precursors
At the Dover trial in 2005, the Brown University biologist Kenneth Miller pointed to peer-reviewed studies identifying a possible precursor of the flagellum, the type III secretory system, which works on its own, and showing that blood clots in whales and dolphins although part of the usual clotting cascade is missing. Expert witnesses also testified that the definition ignores exaptation, in which a precursor had a different, useful function.75
Reply, for the argumentThe evidence offered is not sufficient
Questioned at the trial about publications on the evolution of the immune system, another of his examples, Behe held that they were still not sufficient evidence for it.7
For the argumentSpecified complexity is a mark of design
William Dembski, a philosopher and mathematician, argues in The Design Inference (1998) that events both highly improbable and specified, matching a pattern given independently of them, indicate design. His explanatory filter infers design only when neither law nor chance explains an event: a message from space listing the prime numbers up to 101 in order, as in the film Contact, would pass, while a random run of coin tosses would not.61
Reply, against the argumentLaw, chance, and design can overlap
Ruse answers that the filter treats law, chance, and design as excluding one another, when they need not. A mutation counted as chance may have regular causes we do not yet know, and a designer could work through law, as a pattern woven by machine is as much designed as one woven by hand.6
Against the argument
Against the argumentNatural selection explains the appearance of design
Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) argues that natural selection, working on unplanned variation over long periods, produces living things adapted to their surroundings, and many of the features once cited as evidence of design are such adaptations. In his Autobiography, Darwin wrote that Paley's argument, which had once seemed conclusive to him, fails now that natural selection has been discovered.12
Reply, for the argumentDesign can work through natural processes
Ratzsch and Koperski answer that Paley himself and the authors of the Bridgewater Treatises held that whether something was designed is a largely separate question from how it was produced, and Francis Bacon, more than two centuries before Darwin, wrote of God working through nature's own laws. On this view, natural selection does not explain design away if the processes behind it were designed.1
Reply, against the argumentThen the evidence for design may become ambiguous
The same authors note the cost of this answer. If design-like features arise from unbroken chains of natural causes, a full natural account of them exists at the immediate level, design plays no direct role there, and their force as evidence threatens to become ambiguous.1
Reply, for the argumentNot needed at one level is not needed at none
They add that a design explanation that is not needed at the level of the mechanism may still be needed at a deeper one. The question then becomes whether the laws and conditions that allow life to arise could be free of design, a question that, they note, scientists themselves have increasingly raised.1
Against the argumentNatural processes can produce these features, and God works through them
Theistic evolutionists hold that natural processes, natural selection included, can produce the features of living things, and that God creates through those processes rather than by stepping into them. Theists took up this view soon after Darwin's Origin appeared: the botanist Asa Gray, a devout Presbyterian, argued that natural selection is not inconsistent with natural theology, and the Anglican clergyman Charles Kingsley wrote to Darwin that a God who created first forms able to develop on their own is as noble a conception as one who must intervene to fill gaps he himself had left.82
Reply, for the argumentThe evolution science teaches leaves God no guiding role
Phillip Johnson, a Berkeley law professor and the author of Darwin on Trial (1991), argues that the evolution taught as science is naturalistic: it involves no intervention or guidance by a creator. It fits belief in God, he wrote in 1990, only if God is a first cause who retires once the laws of nature are set in motion, so theists who believe in a guided evolution mean something very different by the word.69
Reply, against the argumentMany theists accept natural explanation in science
Ruse answers that Johnson's creationism is not all there is to Christianity: there are theists who hold that one can explain nature by natural causes alone, which today implies accepting evolution, and Johnson, in Ruse's view, has not argued against them.6
Against the argumentPast gaps in natural explanation have closed
Critics call arguments from what nature cannot do God-of-the-gaps arguments. Ratzsch and Koperski note that such gaps have a spotty track record: new theories have shown natural ways to produce things once thought beyond nature's power, Darwin's theory being the clearest example.1
Reply, for the argumentWhether there are gaps is an empirical question
The same authors add that holding there are gaps in nature is not inherently irrational and seems a legitimate empirical question. The common charge that every design argument appeals to divine intervention in nature's course, they argue, is historically inaccurate, and inaccurate about design arguments today.1
3ConclusionSo living things are the products of intentional design by an intelligent agent.
For the argument
For the argumentDesign is the best explanation
Some defenders present the argument as an inference to the best explanation: design explains the exquisite complexity of living things, and their fitting of means to ends, better than chance or unguided evolution does, and that makes it probably true.1
Reply, against the argumentWe cannot say what a designer would make
Elliott Sober argues that without specific assumptions about the designer, there is no saying how likely a designer would be to produce vertebrate eyes with the features we observe: depending on the assumptions, the value could be anything from zero to one.1
Reply, for the argumentChance is just as vague
Benjamin Jantzen argues that the same problem applies to chance, which is equally vague as a rival explanation. If naturalists may fill out the chance hypothesis to make it less vague, he holds, design theorists should be allowed the same.1
Against the argument
Against the argumentThe Dover court held that intelligent design is not science
In Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District (2005), the federal judge John E. Jones III held that intelligent design is not science, for three reasons: it invokes supernatural causes, its central argument treats whatever evolution has not explained as evidence for design, and its attacks on evolution have been refuted by the scientific community. The court stated that it took no position on whether intelligent design's arguments may be true.7
Reply, for the argumentWhether it is science does not settle the argument
Ratzsch and Koperski reply that whether intelligent design counts as proper science is controversial, and that even if it does not, that alone would not show a defect in design arguments, since science need not exhaust the conclusions evidence can support.1
4From a designer to GodThe designer is God.
What both sides acceptIdentifying the designer as God is a standard but separate second step, often taken by asking what powers the design would require.1
For the argument
For the argumentDesign reveals God and his goodness
Paley held that the existence of God could be proved from the uniform plan of the universe, and that God's goodness could be seen in the exquisite ways living things are fitted to their purposes.2
For the argumentThe scientific case leaves the designer unnamed
Intelligent design's scientific case does not name the designer. Behe is careful not to identify the designer with the Christian God, Ruse notes. In 2001 Behe asked whether the designer of life on earth could be a natural being, and answered that it could be, but that in his judgment this is implausible: at the start of any chain of designers, input from beyond nature was required.65
Reply, against the argumentCritics see a legal strategy in leaving the designer unnamed
Barbara Forrest and Paul Gross argue that intelligent design writers do not call the designer God for political reasons, hoping to get around the constitutional bar on teaching religious doctrine in public schools in the United States.8
Against the argument
Against the argumentDesign would not show a good or infinite God
Hume argued that if things that bring about natural evils, such as the microorganisms that cause disease, show the marks of design, they would presumably have to be laid at the designer's door, eroding its likeness to the wholly good God of tradition. Even the most impressive evidence, he added, could establish only finite power and wisdom, not infinite.1
Reply, for the argumentExplanations can reach beyond their evidence
Ratzsch and Koperski answer that not everyone agreed Hume had fatally damaged the argument, since explanations can properly reach beyond what known effects strictly require, as Newton's theory of gravity did. What can be said about the designer, they hold, depends on the particular marks of design and on what producing them would require.1
Against the argumentA designer would answer for harmful mutations
Ruse asks why a designer able and willing to make very complex systems, because they are very good, does not fix simple errors in DNA that cause some of the worst genetic diseases. Behe treats this as part of the problem of evil, which Ruse calls true but not very helpful: the reason the good was not done still needs explaining.6
Where does the argument come from?
The design argument is ancient, but it had its greatest influence in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. It goes back at least to the Greeks, and a very brief form of it is one of the five ways of Thomas Aquinas (about 1225 to 1274).110 Hume's objections appeared in his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779), before Paley wrote.1
Paley's Natural Theology (1802) was one of the most popular works of theology ever written in English. It was widely read through the first half of the nineteenth century, and it formed part of the standard curriculum at Oxford and Cambridge.2 The Bridgewater Treatises, eight volumes published between 1833 and 1840, were another example of this kind of natural theology. In one, William Buckland argued that the giant sloth, an extinct animal of awkward appearance, was perfectly adapted to its place in nature. Some of its key fossils had been found by Darwin on the voyage of the Beagle.2
Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) offered natural selection as an explanation of the adaptations that design arguments had cited.1 Its reception was not a simple contest between science and religion. The letters Darwin received ranged from complete condemnation to subtle accommodation to active support, the Darwin Correspondence Project notes, and natural selection was often read as an instrument of God's design.2
The intelligent design movement built on the approach of Phillip Johnson, whose Darwin on Trial (1991) cast the dispute over evolution as a clash of philosophies.6 Behe's Darwin's Black Box (1996) and Dembski's The Design Inference (1998) followed.1 In 2004 the school board in Dover, Pennsylvania, tried to bring intelligent design into its biology classes.6 On December 20, 2005, a federal court ruled that teaching it as an alternative to evolution in a public school science class is unconstitutional.7
Across traditions
Views on design and on evolution vary within each faith as well as between them.8
Santaraksita (about 725 to 788) and other Indian Buddhists answered the design reasoning of India's theists.11 The theists' principal argument, Richard Hayes writes, was that the universe is a complex product and so, like all complex products, must have an intelligent maker.11 Buddhist thinkers tended not to reject this, Hayes notes. They generally held that the universe is full of sentient beings everywhere, and that its shape answers to the deeds those beings have done over a history without beginning.11 Santaraksita accepted that products have intelligent causes, but denied that their cause is a single, eternal mind.11 We observe many makers, he argued, and never one will behind them all: it takes many ants to make an anthill and many people to build a city. If one will drove every being, he added, beings would not come into conflict, as they do.11
Buddhist teaching does not set humans apart from other animals as the only beings with souls.8 All beings take part in the cycle of rebirth, and on the doctrine of no-self, the question of a special human soul does not arise.8 Chinese Buddhists who met evolutionary ideas in the 1920s and 1930s did not accept Darwin's theory wholesale.8 The reformer Taixu (1890 to 1947) rejected the struggle for existence as at odds with compassion, and drew instead on Pyotr Kropotkin's account of mutual aid.8 Japanese Nichiren Buddhists accepted much of evolutionary theory but rejected randomness and chance, which, they held, contradict the role of karma in one's circumstances at birth.8
Christian views span a whole spectrum, as Ted Peters and Martinez Hewlett lay it out.8 Young Earth creationists reject both modern geology and evolutionary biology, and Old Earth creationists accept the geology but not the biology.8 Intelligent design, in their account, affirms divine intervention in natural processes, while theistic evolutionists hold that God creates through natural laws.8 In 1996 Pope John Paul II affirmed evolutionary theory, while holding that the human soul is a separate, special creation.8 The Church of England has endorsed evolutionary theory and apologized to Darwin for first rejecting it.8
Design reasoning was the chief case for God in Nyaya, a school of Hindu philosophy.12 It was not Nyaya's alone: Shankara, an Advaita Vedanta philosopher of the eighth century CE, also reasoned from design, Helen De Cruz writes in the Stanford Encyclopedia.8 In ordinary life, he argued, we never see unintelligent things produce purposive design, yet the universe suits human life just as benches and pleasure gardens suit us. Since it is too complex for even an intelligent craftsman to comprehend, unintelligent natural forces could not have made it, and it must have an intelligent creator.8 Shankara held that inference cannot replace the Vedanta texts as the way to know Brahman, though it can confirm what they teach.13
Hindu responses to evolution have been as diverse as Christian ones, De Cruz writes, ranging from creationism, which rejects evolution on the ground that it conflicts with the Vedic texts, to acceptance.8 Vivekananda (1863 to 1902), a proponent of Advaita Vedanta, endorsed evolutionary theory and argued that ancient Vedic texts already prefigured it.8 Devotional (bhakti) traditions recite the heroic deeds of Vishnu's incarnations, or avatars, and the appearances of Shiva.14 Aurobindo Ghose, known as Sri Aurobindo, read the classic doctrine of avatars, in which God takes form in the world again and again, in evolutionary terms.8 He treated both spiritual and physical evolution as manifestations of God (Brahman).8
The Quran describes Adam's special creation from clay, and so most Muslims, De Cruz writes, do not accept that humans evolved from earlier hominins.8 Since the days of creation are often read as long spans of time, old-earth creationism is more influential in Islam than young-earth creationism.8 Muslim scientists such as the physicist Nidhal Guessoum and Rana Dajani have argued for accepting evolution.8 Guessoum holds a principle he takes from Ibn Rushd (Averroes, 1126 to 1198): God's word and God's work, each properly understood, cannot conflict.815
David Solomon Jalajel, a former lecturer in Islamic theology, starts from the traditional Sunni view that Adam and Eve were created without parents.16 He argues that Sunni theology's practice of non-commitment (tawaqquf) on details the sacred texts do not give leaves Muslims who hold that view free to accept, or at least tolerate, the scientific account of human evolution.16
Most branches of Judaism are Rabbinic, holding that scripture should not be read in a simply literal way.8 That leaves room, De Cruz notes, for science at odds with a literal reading of the six days of creation.8 Jewish scholars of the early twentieth century, in Shai Cherry's survey, accepted biological evolution but hesitated over natural selection as its mechanism.8 The rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook (1865 to 1935) drew on Kabbalah and Jewish law to place biological evolution within a cosmic evolution toward perfection.8 The Pittsburgh Platform of 1885, the first document of the Reform rabbinate, declared modern scientific discoveries not opposed to the doctrines of Judaism.8
In the early twentieth century, leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints took no official stance on the theory of evolution, but clarified its teaching on human origins.17 In "The Origin of Man" (1909), its president and his counselors, the First Presidency, affirmed that humans are children of God.17 The apostles James E. Talmage and John A. Widtsoe, both scientists, saw scientific discovery as evidence of God's use of natural laws, while the apostle Joseph Fielding Smith held that the Bible's account of creation left no room for the long spans evolution requires.17 In 1931 the First Presidency asked leaders not to take sides, and to leave geology, biology, archaeology, and anthropology to scientific research.17 In 2016 the Latter-day Saint church's youth magazine restated that "the Church has no official position on the theory of evolution," called evolution a matter for scientific study, and affirmed God's role in creation.17
Where does the debate stand?
All three positions have defenders today. Intelligent design's two main proposals are Behe's irreducible complexity and Dembski's specified complexity, and the movement has met strong opposition.1 Its critics argue that its advocates have the science wrong, that its evidence does not support design, that better explanations exist, and that it is not legitimate science.1 Some philosophers outside the movement have been more sympathetic. Ruse reports that Alvin Plantinga, whom he calls a Calvinist philosopher, reads Behe sympathetically, and that Thomas Nagel, whom he calls openly atheistic, has argued that intelligent design should be taught in public schools as an alternative.6
Among members of the American Association for the Advancement of Science surveyed by Pew in 2009, 97 percent said that humans and other living things have evolved over time, and 87 percent said evolution is due to natural processes such as natural selection.34 The Dover court, which held that intelligent design is not science, added that it did not question that intelligent design should continue to be studied, debated, and discussed.7 Theistic evolution has defenders among scientists and theologians. Miller's Finding Darwin's God (1999) argues that authentic love requires freedom, which the open contingency of evolution supplies. The theologian John Haught sees natural selection as an expression of God's self-giving love, and Plantinga suggests that God may have guided evolution by causing the right mutations to arise at the right time.8
Common questions
What is irreducible complexity?
Irreducible complexity is Michael Behe's term for a system of several well-matched parts, each needed for it to work, such as the flagellum some bacteria use to move. Behe argues that such systems cannot be built directly by slight, successive changes. Critics such as Kenneth Miller answer that parts can come from precursors that once did other jobs.
What did the court decide in Kitzmiller v. Dover?
In 2005 a federal court held that intelligent design is not science, and that teaching it as an alternative to evolution in a public school science class is unconstitutional. It took no position on whether intelligent design's arguments may be true, and did not dispute that intelligent design should continue to be studied, debated, and discussed.
What is theistic evolution?
Theistic evolution is the view that God creates through the laws of nature, including natural selection, rather than by intervening in them. Asa Gray and Charles Kingsley took this view soon after Darwin's Origin appeared, and in 1996 Pope John Paul II affirmed evolutionary theory while holding that the human soul is a special creation.
Read next
Sources
- Del Ratzsch and Jeffrey Koperski. Teleological Arguments for God's Existence. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Darwin Correspondence Project. Darwin and design. Cambridge University Library. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Pew Research Center for the People and the Press. Public Praises Science; Scientists Fault Public, Media. Section 5: Evolution, Climate Change and Other Issues. Pew Research Center, 2009. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Pew Research Center. Scientists and Belief. Pew Research Center, 2009. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Michael J. Behe. Reply to My Critics: A Response to Reviews of Darwin's Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution. Biology and Philosophy 16, 2001. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Michael Ruse. Creationism. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2018. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District, memorandum opinion (December 20, 2005). United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, 2005. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Helen De Cruz. Religion and Science. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Phillip E. Johnson. Evolution as Dogma: The Establishment of Naturalism. First Things (October 1990), 1990. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Robert Pasnau. Thomas Aquinas. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Richard P. Hayes. Principled Atheism in the Buddhist Scholastic Tradition. Journal of Indian Philosophy 16 (1988), pages 5 to 28 (author's copy, University of New Mexico), 1988. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- Matthew R. Dasti. Nyaya. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, introduction and section 3. Accessed 2026-10-29.
- George Thibaut (translator). The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Sankaracarya, part 1 (Sacred Books of the East, volume 34): Sutra 1.1.2. Clarendon Press, 1890; text read at Wisdom Library, 1890, Brahma Sutra 1.1.2. Accessed 2026-10-29.
- John B. Carman. Bhakti. Encyclopedia of Religion (Gale), via Encyclopedia.com, 1987. Accessed 2026-10-29.
- Fouad Ben Ahmed and Robert Pasnau. Ibn Rushd [Averroes]. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-20.
- David Solomon Jalajel. Theological Non-Commitment (Tawaqquf) in Sunni Islam and Its Implications for Muslim Acceptance of Human Evolution. Yaqeen Institute, 2018, notes 1 to 3. Accessed 2026-10-29.
- The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Organic Evolution (Church History Topics). The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Accessed 2026-11-20.